No surprise, but I'm among those fans.
I have nothing at all against the parties involved in its production. Guido Guidi and the other artists involved in the main series get nothing but my respect, especially Guidi having not had a lot of lead time. I do, however, feel that Shane McCarthy needed a lot more time to work on the blasted thing, that he needed to collaborate with Simon Furman, and that whether he respects the man or not, he could have done much better to continue from the framework that Furman had started with than what he did.
Unfortunately, we're pretty much stuck with it. But that doesn't mean I have to like it.
I've been tossing around the idea of doing a fan re-write of AHM for months now. I held off on doing it until after Coda finished off, hoping that would help to fix the assorted continuity gaffes (and aside from Nick Roche's story, not much of that was present), but now, I'm seriously considering doing it once I get more done with my other projects. I even have some firm ideas in mind to expand upon the story, elaborate on the differences, even incorporate concepts and ideas from other corners of the IDW-verse that got little elaboration (Spotlight: Mirage, anyone?). I don't have enough hubris to think it'll be better than the published version, and I no doubt will need some editing assistance of my own, but I like to think someone will enjoy it.
Still, my novel and the re-edits of my own stuff take priority. Once I get more of that done...we'll see.
Devious Comments
Be warned, I wouldn't deviate too much from what was published. I'd just try to smooth out some of the various continuity wrinkles and make it work a little better with Furman's run. Nothing wrong with that, I hope.
--
William Rendfeld
That EchoWing Guy...
Author of "Transformers: Armada (Revisited)"
And there's nothing wrong with that. I'm up for idea-bouncing too.
--
BEHOLD MY HUMAN LASER!!!
spotlight mirage elobration? amazing!
--
"Freedom is the right of Humanity"- Master Commander Comwealth
"An artist's artwork is the evolution of his or her imagination" - The Writer
My Base of Operations: [link]
--
William Rendfeld
That EchoWing Guy...
Author of "Transformers: Armada (Revisited)"
--
William Rendfeld
That EchoWing Guy...
Author of "Transformers: Armada (Revisited)"
--
William Rendfeld
That EchoWing Guy...
Author of "Transformers: Armada (Revisited)"
Previous Page123Next Page